FGF E-Package
The Conservative Curmudgeon
April 11, 2008

Debate on Rev. Wright Ignores Dramatic Gains by Black Community
Time Warp Distorts Present Reality

by Allan C. Brownfeld

The extreme declarations of the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, former pastor of Senator Barack Obama, have led to a widespread discussion of how familiar the senator was with Wright's views and how he could have remained a member of such a church for so long. The discussion has raised the larger issue of the radical liberation theology espoused by some of the most outspoken clergymen of black churches.

Some of the Rev. Wright's statements -- charging the U.S. government developed HIV/AIDS to destroy black Americans, or declaring that the CIA has distributed drugs within the nation's inner cities to harm the black community -- are demonstrably false. His overall thesis -- our racist society prevents black Americans from advancing -- represents something of a time-warped view. It is as if segregation had not been eliminated long ago, as if civil rights legislation going back to l964 had not been passed to ensure the rights of all Americans.

The Politics of Victimhood
"I've known preachers like the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, Jr.," wrote Jonetta Rose Barras, a political analyst for National Public Radio in THE WASHINGTON POST. "Like many of them, he no doubt sees his congregation as full of victims... Once upon a time, I saw myself as a victim, too, destined to march in place. In the l970s and 1980s, as a clenched-fist-pumping black nationalist... I reflected that self-contempt in my speech... More than a few times, I, too, damned America loudly for its treatment of blacks."

As time went by, however, Barras declares that, "I turned away from such rhetoric... That other African-Americans and I were able to overcome seemingly insurmountable hurdles is undeniably due, in part, to Wright-like prophetic speech. Like Negro spirituals, it helped us organize, motivate, and empower ourselves. But just as spirituals eventually lost their relevance and potency... so, I believe, has Wright-speak lost its place. It's harmful and ultimately can't provide healing. And it's outdated in the 2lst century."

In one of his recent syndicated columns, economist Walter Williams points out that Senator Obama's success "is truly a remarkable commentary on the goodness of Americans and how far we've come in resolving matters of race. I'm 72 years old. For almost all my life, a black having a real chance at becoming the President of the United States was at best a pipe dream. Mr. Obama has convincingly won primaries in states with insignificant black populations. As such, it further confirms what I've often said: The civil rights struggle in America is over and it's won."

In Williams' view, "While not every single vestige of racial discrimination has disappeared, Mr. Obama and Mr. Wright are absolutely wrong in suggesting racial discrimination is anywhere near the major problem confronting a large segment of the black community. The major problems are family breakdown, illegitimacy, fraudulent education, and a high rate of criminality. Confronting these problems, that are not the fault of the larger society, require political courage..."

True Causes of Poverty
The notions that racial progress in recent years has not been dramatic, and that our society is mired in the racism and divisions that characterized earlier periods are simply wrong.

Journalist Juan Williams provides interesting insights in his book, ENOUGH: The poverty rate for black men and women who finish high school or college, take a job and hold it, and have children only after 2l and married is 6.4 percent. This contrasts sharply with the overall poverty rate for black Americans of 21.5 percent, based on 2002 census data. By 2004, the poverty rate for those who follow the formula of education, work, and marriage was 5.8 percent, while the overall poverty rate for blacks was 24.7 percent. In fact, white Americans have a higher poverty rate than blacks who finished high school, married, and worked for at least a year.

The problems within the inner city black community are not the result of white racism but rather of a breakdown of values within that community. In 2002, most black children--68 percent--were born to unwed mothers. These numbers have real consequences. Thirty-five percent of black women who had children out of wedlock lives in poverty. Only l7 percent of married black women lives in poverty.

In 2005, l.l million black Americans over age 25 had advanced degrees compared to about 677,000 in l995. In their recent book, COME ON PEOPLE, comedian Bill Cosby and psychiatrist Alvin Poussaint declare that, "The doors of opportunity are no longer locked, and we have to walk through." In 2002, the number of black-owned businesses stood at l.2 million--a rise of 45 percent since l997.

Rev. Wright is, in many ways, an inauthentic figure. He presents himself as a spokesman for those who have suffered from poverty, deprivation, and racism. Yet his own background was decidedly privileged. He lived in a tree-lined neighborhood of large stone houses in Philadelphia's Germantown section. Wright's father was a prominent pastor, and his mother was a teacher and later vice principal of the distinguished Philadelphia's High School for Girls. Both of Wright's parents earned Ph.Ds. Wright attended the highly selective and overwhelmingly white Central High School.

Jeremiah Wright's message has little relationship to the reality of today's America, which is far more open, tolerant, and accessible to men and women of all races than his parishioners would ever imagine from his sermons.

Back to The Conservative Curmudgeon archives



The Conservative Curmudgeon is copyright © 2008 by the Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation, www.fgfBooks.com. All rights reserved. Permission is granted to forward this column if credit is given to the author and the Foundation.

Allan C. Brownfeld is the author of five books, the latest of which is THE REVOLUTION LOBBY (Council for Inter-American Security). He has been a staff aide to a U.S. Vice President, Members of Congress, and the U.S. Senate Internal Subcommittee.

He is associate editor of THE LINCOLN REVIEW and a contributing editor to such publications as HUMAN EVENTS, THE ST. CROIX REVIEW, and THE WASHINGTON REPORT ON MIDDLE EAST AFFAIRS.

To sponsor the FGF E-Package:
please send a tax-deductible donation to the
Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation
P.O. Box 1383
Vienna,VA 22183
or sponsor online.

© 2008 Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation